|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1149
Good find that  , clears up my question about a goalie going up for a corner.
As for a goalkeeper accidentally slipping/stumbling, then as he had the ball in his hands inside the box then in my opinion this rule should apply and no more.
'A handball outside the penalty area is always penalized with a direct free kick'
In the Henderson case if there were no VAR then the handball would've not been noticed
But there was VAR so it's subjective, was there an obvious goal scoring situation?
My opinion is I'm unsure, so I give the benefit of doubt and say no.
|
|
| | | Cam | | Posts: 6545 |  | | MODERATOR | |
|
In reply to Post #1146
Here are the rules:
A goalkeeper committing a handball outside their penalty area results in a direct free kick for the opposing team. If the handball denies a clear goal-scoring opportunity, the goalkeeper may also receive a yellow card, and potentially a red card if the opportunity is deemed obvious.
Key Points:
Direct Free Kick:
A handball outside the penalty area is always penalized with a direct free kick.
Yellow/Red Card:
The goalkeeper may also receive a caution or a red card if the handball denies an obvious goal-scoring opportunity.
Same Restrictions as Outfield Players:
Outside the penalty area, a goalkeeper is subject to the same handball rules as any other player.
Penalty Area Definition:
The penalty area is defined by the line, and if any part of the ball is over the line, it is considered inside the penalty area, allowing the goalkeeper to use their hands.
VAR Intervention:
VAR can intervene if the handball outside the area denies a clear goal-scoring opportunity, potentially leading to a red card.
VAR intervention is was stopped Henderson being sent off IMO.
And as for the keeper going up for a corner and handles it, well he's obviously not Allison  and is classed as an outfield player, so it would be handball. i.e. Same Restrictions as Outfield Players
Lineker ? Meeh
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1147
He's going early. Bonus
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1146
Some interesting points you've raised there. All players should be treated the same.
Bye bye Lineker. 👋👋
To**er.
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1145
You may be right but an outfield player wouldn't, so why should a goalkeeper?
Also what if a goalkeeper catches the ball inside the box but accidently slides on a wet pitch out of the box, a sending off would be harsh. Not even a yellow in my book, just a free kick to the opposition
Another scenario, in the last dying seconds the goalkeeper goes up to the other end of the pitch for the last corner of the game. He jumps to head the ball but it hits his hand.
Should he be sent off?
As I say it's all subjective and open to interpretation.
|
|
| | | Cam | | Posts: 6545 | | | MODERATOR | |
|
In reply to Post #1144
I always thought if the keeper handled outside the box they was off but, obviously not the case.
Would have spoiled the game if he had gone IMO.
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1143
All subjective.
If it wasn't a goal scoring opportunity then it would be a yellow card IMO
|
|
| | | Cam | | Posts: 6545 | | | MODERATOR | |
|
Fully deserved by Palace.
Not sure how they got away with the Henderson handball but he ho !
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1141
Take it your am fan then, amazing result for the club that
|
|
|
|
My first ever post in the non fishing section.
My head hurts, my liver is strained and I am an emotional wreck.
CRYSTAL PALACE FA CUP WINNERS
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1139
Really!!!
Really pleased to hear that, purposely didn’t watch it, get in, they loooked solid in the semi. Well done Crystal Palace  
Pep out 
|
|
|
|
Well done Palace. Really pleased for you.
No trophy for the 115ers. Pep didn't look to please
|
|
|
|
Hill Dickinson pulled a blinder here.
They sponsored Everton’s new ground and it’s going to cost them **** all….
Apparently it’s “No Win, No Fee”
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1135
Chris wood Nottingham forest
Thought he would have retired by now
Must be almost 60 by now..
|
|
|
|
In reply to Post #1135
Mo salad, again!
Nuno at forest, outstanding performance really
|
|
